pz619 wroteLets be real every1 records everything now a days. Its first thing people do when something goes down, cellphone and record button.Apples to Oranges. When was the last time you heard of one party suing another for window tint? Never?
How often do people get sued over privacy violation? All the time. Point is, if nothing is broken on the car then there isn't really any restitution here. Push too hard, the business might make an issue of the audio recording. Doubt it would go to any sort of litigation, but who wants the headache in the first place.
74.4KVIEWS
94REPLIES
64APPRECIATES
41ACTIVE PEOPLE
11-25-2019LAST POST
11-16-2019
11-16-2019
nyalpine90
Lieutenant General
7,984
REP
12.2K
POSTS
11-16-2019
11-16-2019
Our03z4
Captain
1,801
REP
702
POSTS
ShopVac wroteEh, I just like thinking people aren't as bad as they are...it screws me sometimes. The fact that he jacked with the headliner makes me take back my comment. Good luck to you and I hope it all works out!Every dash cam I have (3 different brands over 5 cars) all have a shut off voltage for park mode recording. The camera will not drain the battery dead...but it sounds like I should thank him for thinking of my cars well fair
11-16-2019
11-16-2019
pz619
Brigadier General
3,476
REP
3.4K
POSTS
nyalpine90 wrotehttps://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/a32124/the-surprising-legal-ramifications-of-having-a-dash-cam-in-your-car/Lets be real every1 records everything now a days. Its first thing people do when something goes down, cellphone and record button.
This article by Steve Lehto covers it pretty well. Video is pretty clear on the audio portion of the recording. Laws vary from state to state, so you’ll have to look it up in your own to see how applicable this is to your home state.
11-16-2019
11-16-2019
RM7
Brigadier General
3,163
REP
3.8K
POSTS
Yapakanichi wroteFor what damages? How are you going to prove that anything is related to what you don't know happened while it was disconnected?
I'd lawyer up too for damages (foot stomp) while the car was in their hands if they don't play nice. Maybe you have a case, maybe you don't. And if you're a lawyer, stomp em.
You might be able to leverage an extended warranty if you can show some substantial evidence, like significantly different odometer readings, you took a picture before hand and after, can pull some data from the ECU, etc., but that could be effectively fought if you can't show that said driving was actually causing damage, leaving you with possibly recapping maybe a rental fee, since they were using your car.
11-16-2019
11-16-2019
F32Fleet
Lieutenant General
4,227
REP
10.9K
POSTS
ShopVac wroteYou can't force them to accept being recorded.F32Fleet wroteWhy in the fuck would that be? It's my personal property, part of my car.They have every right to disconnect the camera.
Do they have the right to go through my glove box, centre console and trunk while there?
If the lot attendant raced my car around the lot and wrecked it...I have every right to know.
You can attempt to record (video only) them w/out their knowledge and not get into trouble.
Viffermike
11-16-2019
11-16-2019
vreihen16
Recovering Perfectionist
30,613
REP
1.1K
POSTS
F32Fleet wroteThere are side window stickers for sale on Amazon and other sites for ride-share drivers who have passenger-facing cameras, cautioning passengers that there are cameras recording the inside of the vehicle and that entering the door is consent to being recorded. I wonder if that is enough to be considered consent to being recorded for valet purposes?You can't force them to accept being recorded.
I live in New Yorkistan, and we are a single-party consent state for audio recordings. Even so, I have the audio recording function disabled on all of my vehicle dashcams, in case I ever have to turn the raw video files over in court.....
11-16-2019
11-16-2019
F32Fleet
Lieutenant General
4,227
REP
10.9K
POSTS
vreihen16 wroteGreat question, The valet may add verbiage to their ticket given to the car owner in an attempt to invalidate that. A good question for a lawyer.F32Fleet wroteThere are side window stickers for sale on Amazon and other sites for ride-share drivers who have passenger-facing cameras, cautioning passengers that there are cameras recording the inside of the vehicle and that entering the door is consent to being recorded. I wonder if that is enough to be considered consent to being recorded for valet purposes?You can't force them to accept being recorded.
I live in New Yorkistan, and we are a single-party consent state for audio recordings. Even so, I have the audio recording function disabled on all of my vehicle dashcams, in case I ever have to turn the raw video files over in court.....
vreihen16
11-19-2019
11-19-2019
OkieSnuffBox
Major
1,806
REP
1K
POSTS
rlmesq wroteMy first job out of college was as a claim rep for State Farm. When someone threatened legal action............it was my favorite thing.Some people think every problem in life is a way to hit the lawsuit jackpot... but any lawyer knows this situation isn't worth the time and effort to sue anybody.
And no lawyer with half a brain would try to "stomp em" because the other side would file an anti-SLAPP action, and the lawyer would end up paying the parking lot's legal fees as well.
When people start threatening to call lawyers, most businesses just say, "fine, have your lawyer call our legal department" and stop trying to resolve the issue. That's because they know the customer will suffer sticker shock when they find out a lawyer wants a $5,000 retainer to take on their ten dollar dispute.
Once they threaten legal action, we informed them from this point forward we would no longer be communicating and all information would pass between their lawyer and our team of 800+ corporate lawyers.
rlmesq
11-19-2019
11-19-2019
OkieSnuffBox
Major
1,806
REP
1K
POSTS
Am I the only that takes a picture of the odometer any time I valet, drop off for service, etc?
But when it comes to the airport, now I just take an Uber there and back. About the same as parking would be and my car gets to stay at home in the garage.
But when it comes to the airport, now I just take an Uber there and back. About the same as parking would be and my car gets to stay at home in the garage.
FuriouslyFast
11-19-2019
11-19-2019
FuriouslyFast
Banned
873
REP
407
POSTS
OkieSnuffBox wroteaka corporate america is going to screw you again b/c $My first job out of college was as a claim rep for State Farm. When someone threatened legal action............it was my favorite thing.
Once they threaten legal action, we informed them from this point forward we would no longer be communicating and all information would pass between their lawyer and our team of 800+ corporate lawyers.


11-19-2019
11-19-2019
MPBK
Everyday I'm shuffling
465
REP
1.1K
POSTS
Our03z4 wroteBSHere is my guess. He unplugged it worried it would drain the battery. It was already parked when he saw the camera.
pz619 wroteMore BSWorth noting that some states it’s illegal to record without consent, especially audio recordings. Not taking sides here, just advising caution as your videos contain audio and PA is a 2 party consent state (assuming that’s where the video was taken).
Yapakanichi wroteGet realThis is going to be a big lesson hopefully learned. OP I say make it rain on his parade. I wouldn't allow that to happen.
I'd lawyer up too for damages (foot stomp) while the car was in their hands if they don't play nice. Maybe you have a case, maybe you don't. And if you're a lawyer, stomp em.
F32Fleet wroteTroll.They have every right to disconnect the camera.
MKSixer
,
Socal_R8
11-19-2019
11-19-2019
JayML
Lieutenant
92
REP
418
POSTS
Any time I leave my car anywhere I put the actual KM on a piece of paper and leave it on the Instrument panel for anyone who moves the car to see. I do not even round the decimal point.
If its 9544.3km that is what I put. Never had a problem .
If its 9544.3km that is what I put. Never had a problem .
11-19-2019
11-19-2019
N54Yankee
Lieutenant Colonel
2,708
REP
1.9K
POSTS
I’d be quite hot and let them know it. Depending on how they reacted to me knowing would dictate how I proceeded from there.
11-19-2019
11-19-2019
OkieSnuffBox
Major
1,806
REP
1K
POSTS
FuriouslyFast wroteIt's really more the insured people are pissed they didn't read the contract and are pissed that everything isn't covered carte blanche.aka corporate america is going to screw you again b/c $
So as always, RTFM.
11-20-2019
11-20-2019
rlmesq
Lieutenant Colonel
1,045
REP
1.5K
POSTS
FuriouslyFast wroteIdiots who go around threatening to sue people don't need "corporate america" to screw them. They do it very nicely on their own, without help.aka corporate america is going to screw you again b/c $OkieSnuffBox wroteMy first job out of college was as a claim rep for State Farm. When someone threatened legal action............it was my favorite thing.
Once they threaten legal action, we informed them from this point forward we would no longer be communicating and all information would pass between their lawyer and our team of 800+ corporate lawyers.
OkieSnuffBox
11-20-2019
11-20-2019
Ric in RVA
Bergspyder
1,665
REP
1.3K
POSTS
OkieSnuffBox wroteHa! You too?My first job out of college was as a claim rep for State Farm. When someone threatened legal action............it was my favorite thing.
Once they threaten legal action, we informed them from this point forward we would no longer be communicating and all information would pass between their lawyer and our team of 800+ corporate lawyers.
"I am sorry I can't speak with you...since you are represented.....no you need to speak to your attorney and have them contact us......no I am hanging up now!"
Fire claims!! 28 years ago and an agent for 21 years.
Been a good run!
11-20-2019
11-20-2019
OkieSnuffBox
Major
1,806
REP
1K
POSTS
Ric in RVA wroteYep, fire claims. Specifically on the theft and PAP claims team. I didn't pass the agent personality test so I lost interest in staying.Ha! You too?
"I am sorry I can't speak with you...since you are represented.....no you need to speak to your attorney and have them contact us......no I am hanging up now!"
Fire claims!! 28 years ago and an agent for 21 years.
Been a good run!
11-20-2019
11-20-2019
FuriouslyFast
Banned
873
REP
407
POSTS
rlmesq wroteYes, THOSE idiots, but let's not act like insurance is not a giant scam to begin with so...Idiots who go around threatening to sue people don't need "corporate america" to screw them. They do it very nicely on their own, without help.
11-20-2019
11-20-2019
FuriouslyFast
Banned
873
REP
407
POSTS
OkieSnuffBox wroteNo one reads the fine print, man. The companies know this...It's really more the insured people are pissed they didn't read the contract and are pissed that everything isn't covered carte blanche.
So as always, RTFM.
11-20-2019
11-20-2019
OkieSnuffBox
Major
1,806
REP
1K
POSTS
FuriouslyFast wroteHow is it a scam? Haven't they come out recently and said like 50% of Americans would have a problem coming up with $1000 for an unexpected emergency.................how are those people going to pay for my car if they crash into it without insurance?Yes, THOSE idiots, but let's not act like insurance is not a giant scam to begin with so...
FuriouslyFast wroteIf you enter a contract, without reading the contract, whose fault is that?No one reads the fine print, man. The companies know this...
11-20-2019
11-20-2019
FuriouslyFast
Banned
873
REP
407
POSTS
OkieSnuffBox wrotelol come on, you're trolling. Do we get some of our premium back for not getting into an accident? Nope.How is it a scam? Haven't they come out recently and said like 50% of Americans would have a problem coming up with $1000 for an unexpected emergency.................how are those people going to pay for my car if they crash into it without insurance?
If you enter a contract, without reading the contract, whose fault is that?
Good day
11-20-2019
11-20-2019
TSM330i
2006 330i, TSM, Black, manual, sport
946
REP
3.7K
POSTS
Why don't you take the car to the dealership to see if they can download the data? I believe it does record a bit of time in the cars computer for references in the case of an accident.

